Puritan family arriving in New England during the Great Migration, unloading belongings on a rocky shore near an early colonial settlement while Indigenous inhabitants observe from the woodland

Puritanism, Dissent and the Great Migration

  1. The Reformation in the British Isles: Causes and Legacy
  2. English Expansionism: From the British Isles to the Atlantic Empire
  3. The Glorious Revolution of 1688: Causes and Legacy
  4. The American Colonies: Religion, Politics and Self-Government
  5. USA: Birth of a Nation — From Independence to the Constitution
  6. The Stuart Crisis and the Wars of the Three Kingdoms
  7. The English Civil War and Cromwell’s Commonwealth
  8. The Restoration and the Road to the Glorious Revolution
  9. Puritanism, Dissent and the Great Migration

The Great Migration carried thousands of English Puritans to New England during the 1630s. They did not simply flee persecution in search of individual religious freedom. Instead, they intended to establish disciplined Protestant communities governed through covenant, scripture and collective responsibility. Their settlements encouraged literacy, local government and political participation among selected colonists, while also enforcing conformity and expanding across Indigenous homelands.

The Puritan migration formed part of the wider religious and constitutional history of the British Atlantic. The previous article examined how the Glorious Revolution protected a Protestant political order while leaving the position of religious minorities unresolved.

What was Puritanism?

Puritanism emerged from the English Reformation during the late sixteenth century. Puritans accepted the Protestant break with Rome but believed that the Church of England still preserved too many Catholic ceremonies, institutions and assumptions.

They objected to practices such as elaborate vestments, ceremonial worship and the authority of bishops. They instead emphasised scripture, preaching, moral discipline and the direct examination of personal faith.

Puritanism was not one organised denomination. The term covered ministers, theologians, lay believers and political reformers who disagreed about church government, worship and the limits of obedience to the established Church.

Most Puritans remained members of the Church of England and sought to reform it from within. Others concluded that no true Christian congregation could remain inside an institution they considered corrupt. These more radical believers became known as Separatists.

Lire Puritanism, Dissent and the Great Migration

Charles II restored to the English throne as Parliament, Anglican bishops and Dutch ships foreshadow the political and religious crisis leading to the Glorious Revolution

The Restoration and the Road to the Glorious Revolution

  1. The Reformation in the British Isles: Causes and Legacy
  2. English Expansionism: From the British Isles to the Atlantic Empire
  3. The Glorious Revolution of 1688: Causes and Legacy
  4. The American Colonies: Religion, Politics and Self-Government
  5. USA: Birth of a Nation — From Independence to the Constitution
  6. The Stuart Crisis and the Wars of the Three Kingdoms
  7. The English Civil War and Cromwell’s Commonwealth
  8. The Restoration and the Road to the Glorious Revolution
  9. Puritanism, Dissent and the Great Migration

The Restoration of 1660 returned the monarchy, Parliament and the Church of England, but it did not restore the political world that had existed before the Civil War. Charles II governed within a society transformed by regicide, republican government, religious pluralism and military rule. The settlement survived for twenty-five years, yet conflicts over Catholicism, dissent, royal prerogative and the succession eventually prepared the overthrow of James II in 1688.

The Restoration followed eleven years of republican experiments. Before examining how monarchy returned, revisit the New Model Army, the execution of Charles I, the Commonwealth and Oliver Cromwell’s Protectorate.

Why was the monarchy restored in 1660?

Oliver Cromwell’s death in September 1658 exposed the fragility of the Protectorate. His son Richard inherited the office of Lord Protector but lacked military authority, political experience and a dependable group of supporters. He resigned in May 1659 after failing to reconcile Parliament with senior army officers.

The following months brought repeated constitutional breakdowns. The army recalled the Rump Parliament, expelled it and then restored it again. Competing officers and politicians claimed to defend the republican cause, but none could establish a government with broad legitimacy.

England had grown weary of military intervention, irregular taxation and constitutional uncertainty. Many former Parliamentarians concluded that monarchy offered the best prospect of stable civilian government. Their support did not mean that they had abandoned every principle defended during the Civil War.

General George Monck commanded the English army occupying Scotland. During the winter of 1659–1660, he marched south while presenting himself as a defender of lawful parliamentary government. His intentions remained deliberately uncertain until he had secured control of London and the army.

Monck allowed the MPs excluded during Pride’s Purge to return to the Long Parliament. That restored assembly dissolved itself and authorised elections for a new Parliament. Because no king existed to summon it, the resulting body became known as the Convention Parliament.

Lire The Restoration and the Road to the Glorious Revolution

Oliver Cromwell standing with Parliamentarian soldiers during the English Civil War, with Westminster, a broken crown and the execution scaffold behind him

The English Civil War and Cromwell’s Commonwealth

  1. The Reformation in the British Isles: Causes and Legacy
  2. English Expansionism: From the British Isles to the Atlantic Empire
  3. The Glorious Revolution of 1688: Causes and Legacy
  4. The American Colonies: Religion, Politics and Self-Government
  5. USA: Birth of a Nation — From Independence to the Constitution
  6. The Stuart Crisis and the Wars of the Three Kingdoms
  7. The English Civil War and Cromwell’s Commonwealth
  8. The Restoration and the Road to the Glorious Revolution
  9. Puritanism, Dissent and the Great Migration

Parliament’s victory in the English Civil War destroyed the political order that its leaders had originally claimed to defend. The New Model Army defeated Charles I, challenged Parliament and helped bring the king to trial. England then abolished monarchy and the House of Lords, established a Commonwealth and eventually placed Oliver Cromwell at the head of a written constitutional regime.

The war emerged from a crisis that affected three kingdoms rather than England alone. Scottish resistance, the Irish Rebellion and the conflict between Charles I and Parliament had already transformed the Stuart monarchy before the first major English battle.

From political breakdown to civil war

Charles I raised his royal standard at Nottingham on 22 August 1642. The ceremony conventionally marks the beginning of open war between the king and Parliament in England. However, neither side entered the conflict with a complete political programme or a professional national army.

Royalists claimed that they defended lawful monarchy against subjects who had exceeded Parliament’s constitutional authority. Parliamentarians argued that they protected Protestant religion, parliamentary privilege and the laws of the kingdom from corrupt royal advisers. Both sides therefore presented themselves as defenders of the traditional constitution.

The population did not divide neatly into two ideological camps. Families, towns and counties often contained supporters of both causes. Personal loyalty, religion, local rivalries, economic interests and the presence of nearby troops all influenced the choice of allegiance.

Many people tried to remain neutral. Yet armies required horses, food, weapons, accommodation and taxes. As military mobilisation expanded, neutrality became increasingly difficult to maintain.

Lire The English Civil War and Cromwell’s Commonwealth